Hutchinson Kansas Newspaper

collapse
Home / Daily News Analysis / ‘That's on me’: Rebuked by India, JD Vance walks back ‘indentured servants’ remarks over H-1B workers

‘That's on me’: Rebuked by India, JD Vance walks back ‘indentured servants’ remarks over H-1B workers

Oct 18, 2026  Twila Rosenbaum 39 views
‘That's on me’: Rebuked by India, JD Vance walks back ‘indentured servants’ remarks over H-1B workers

Washington, DC: US Vice President JD Vance has acknowledged that his description of some H-1B visa holders as 'indentured servants' was poorly worded, after India sharply criticized the language as offensive and dismissive of Indian professionals' contributions to the American economy.

Speaking at a televised town hall, Vance said his remarks had been aimed at companies and an immigration system that can leave foreign employees dependent on their employers to remain in the United States. He said his choice of words had been imperfect and clarified that he was referring to certain H-1B holders and employment practices, not the entire category of visa workers.

'To the extent my rhetoric has been imperfect, that's on me. What I said about certain visa holders, certain H-1B holders, is not for the entire category. This is what happens often when they come in with an H-1B and the company is certifying that they are doing a job that they cannot find an alternative American laborer apt for it. Importantly, their visa is their only lifeline to the United States of America,' he said.

He argued that workers could face deportation if they lost their jobs or disagreed with their employers, giving companies considerable control over their employment and immigration status. In his account, the visa structure can leave a worker with little practical room to challenge a sponsor or bargain for better terms without risking the right to stay in the country.

Earlier remarks set off a diplomatic dispute

Vance had used the phrase earlier in the month during a news conference on alleged visa fraud. He accused foreign outsourcing companies of using H-1B workers to undercut the wages of American employees and argued that the practice allowed businesses to reduce labor costs. He claimed that an H-1B worker earns $20,000 less than an American citizen hired in the same position, and that a worker brought in by a foreign outsourcing firm earns $48,000 less than an American citizen in a similar role.

He also accused companies of replacing American workers with foreign employees brought in through the visa program. 'You bring in indentured servants from outside the country, you lay off American workers and, if you are a corporation, you make a ton of money by undercutting the wages of American workers, replacing them with people who frankly shouldn't be in the United States of America to begin with,' he said at the time.

The remarks drew a sharp response from India's Ministry of External Affairs, which said the description disregarded the contribution of Indian professionals to the US economy and its innovation sector. 'We have also seen some comments in this context by the US vice president. We believe that such descriptions are unwarranted and ignore the fact that Indian professionals in the United States are highly educated and skilled contributors to its economy and innovation ecosystem,' the ministry said in a statement.

The ministry also referred to the historical associations of the term. 'Indeed, the history of the United States itself has been shaped by generations of immigrants whose labor, enterprise and innovation have contributed to its growth and prosperity. Resorting to terminology that carries painful historical and colonial legacy connotations is deeply offensive,' it added.

Vance tries to separate workers from the system

In his subsequent remarks, Vance sought to draw a distinction between the workers and the system. He argued that workers could face deportation if they lost their jobs or disagreed with their employers, giving companies considerable control over their employment and immigration status. He said the phrase was meant to describe the power employers hold over foreign workers whose right to stay in the United States depends on their jobs.

'So, when I say indentured servitude, that is not a criticism of H-1B visa holders; that is the criticism of the company, which brings a person who sometimes will lay off an American worker and knows that if they complain, if they have disagreement with the boss, they could just lose their job. They can be shipped back, which I think gives way too much power to the employer. Maybe my rhetoric has been imperfect here. It is the criticism of the visa system that allowed people to be treated as indentured servants, as they can be shipped to their countries of origin,' he said.

The clarification did not withdraw the underlying argument. Vance continued to criticize employers that he said exploit the visa system, and he maintained that the program can give companies leverage over workers who depend on sponsorship to remain in the United States. The distinction matters politically because it redirects criticism from a broad group of skilled immigrants toward companies and the legal architecture of the visa.

Key facts in the dispute

  • Vance used the phrase 'indentured servants' while discussing alleged visa fraud and the effect of H-1B hiring on wages.
  • He later said his rhetoric was imperfect and that his criticism was aimed at employers and the visa system, not all H-1B holders.
  • India's foreign ministry called the terminology unwarranted and offensive, citing the historical and colonial legacy of indenture.
  • The H-1B program is employer-sponsored, capped for most new visas, and heavily used by skilled workers from India.
  • The dispute touches on broader US debates over immigration, labor costs, outsourcing and employer power.

How the H-1B system creates employer dependence

The H-1B program allows US employers to temporarily hire foreign workers in specialty occupations that typically require at least a bachelor's degree or equivalent. The visa is employer-sponsored, and the number of new visas is capped each year at 65,000, with an additional 20,000 reserved for workers who hold advanced degrees from US institutions. Certain employers, including universities and nonprofit research organizations, are exempt from the cap. Demand consistently exceeds supply, and the government uses a lottery to select petitions.

For many workers, the visa is tied to the sponsoring employer. A job loss can trigger a limited grace period to find new sponsorship or change status, and long backlogs for employment-based green cards, particularly for applicants from India, can keep workers in dependent status for years. Critics say this structure gives employers outsized leverage; supporters say it fills skill shortages and supports innovation.

Indian nationals have historically been among the largest recipients of H-1B visas, particularly in technology, engineering, medicine and research. The program is central to the business models of many US technology companies and global outsourcing firms, and it is also a major issue in US-India relations. Indian professionals in the United States span roles from software engineers to physicians and university researchers, and their contributions are often cited by industry groups and diplomats.

The visa system's dependence on employer sponsorship has long been a subject of debate. Workers can apply for permanent residence while on H-1B status, but country-specific caps and processing delays have created multiyear backlogs for Indian applicants. In practice, many workers remain tied to a sponsoring employer for much of their time in the United States, while changing jobs requires a new petition and carries administrative risk. Employers, for their part, say the program is essential for accessing specialized talent and that compliance rules are already extensive.

Wage claims and the outsourcing argument

The wage claims made by Vance have also touched a long-running argument over the program's effect on American workers. Supporters of the H-1B system say it helps companies fill shortages in


Source:MSN News


Share:

Your experience on this site will be improved by allowing cookies Cookie Policy